A messy desk vs a tidy desk. Which wins?

Reading time: About 3 minutes

Messy desk or tidy one? Research suggests clutter sparks creative drafting while order helps editing. Match your desk to the job.

When I was in grade nine one of my classmates put a sign on her desk.

It said, “A tidy desk is the sign of a frightened mind.” (It really irritated our teacher, which to me was only a plus.)

I admired my classmate’s gumption even though I absolutely cannot write with a messy desk.

But I don’t think I’m better than anyone else because I’m wired the way I am.

Just to show you how disorganized I can be, sometimes I’ll even sweep my arm across my desk and empty the contents into a cardboard box. It’s a really fast way to get a tidy desk.

So, which wins? The messy desk or the tidy one? I don’t think either does, and I’ll defend your right to a desk that looks like a recycling depot exploded.

Researchers have studied this question, and what they found is more useful than the decluttering lectures you’ve heard from an organizing guru with a podcast and a label maker.

What a messy desk is good for

In 2013, Kathleen Vohs and her colleagues at the University of Minnesota put volunteers in one of two rooms: a neat one, or one strewn with papers and assorted junk.

The volunteers then dreamed up new uses for ping-pong balls, and independent judges rated the ideas from the messy room as more creative. In another part of the study, people in the messy room were more likely to pick an option labelled “new” over one labelled “classic.”

What a tidy desk is good for

People in the neat room behaved differently. They gave more than twice as much money to charity as the people in the messy room, and when offered a snack, they were more likely to choose an apple over chocolate.

Put crudely, a tidy desk makes you a better person but a duller one, and you’ll have to decide whether that’s worth giving up the chocolate.

The researchers argue that order nudges us toward convention, while disorder gives us permission to break away from it. I don’t see either tendency as bad. They suit different jobs.

A single set of experiments doesn’t settle anything, and I wouldn’t bet the farm on this one.

Still, the results fit with something I’ve been saying for 25 years.

Match your desk to the job

You’ve heard me say that writing and editing are separate tasks that need separate brains, and this study hints that they might need separate desks.

When you’re drafting, you want odd ideas and fresh connections, and a bit of chaos on the desk may help you make the kind of strange leaps that turn a dull outline into something people want to read. When you’re editing, you need consistency and the nerve to cut your favourite sentence, which calls for the apple-eating, rule-following brain.

Before your next editing session, try spending five minutes clearing the surface in front of you. Before your next drafting session, don’t bother. The mess may be doing some of the work for you.

Pilers and filers

In 1983, Thomas Malone, now a professor at MIT, studied how office workers organized their desks. He sorted them into two camps: filers, who put everything away in a system, and pilers, who let things stack up.

You’d expect the filers to come out ahead, but they don’t always. In 2001, Steve Whittaker and Julia Hirschberg followed workers at AT&T Labs through an office move. The filers had stuffed their cabinets with documents they’d put away too soon and never looked at again. Economist Tim Harford, writing about the research, describes their cabinets as “highly structured waste-paper baskets.”

The filers found the move painful, and one called it “gruesome … you’re casting off your first-born.” (As the mother of triplets, I had three first-borns, so I’m not sure where that leaves me.) The pilers coped better. Their stacks worked as a short-term holding area, and every so often they tossed big chunks without a pang.

The test that matters has nothing to do with looks: can you find what you need in less than a minute? If you can, your system works, no matter what your colleague with the colour-coded binders says. If you can’t, you have a problem, whether your desk is a disaster or a showroom.

The real culprit might be your eyeballs

Princeton neuroscientists Stephanie McMains and Sabine Kastner found that objects in your field of view compete for your brain’s attention and suppress one another, which makes it harder to focus on the one thing you care about.

So that stapler beside your keyboard isn’t just sitting there minding its own business. It’s lobbying.

This suggests a compromise for people who can’t bear to part with their piles. Keep the patch directly in front of your screen clear, and push everything else to the side, or even behind you, where your eyes won’t keep snagging on it.

While you’re at it, have a look at your computer desktop. If it holds 147 icons, including four called “Untitled,” the paper on your desk is not your biggest problem.

So, about that sign

My grade nine classmate was only half wrong. Mess may help a first draft and order may help an edit, but neither says a thing about your personality. The right desk is the one that lets you find your notes and get on with the writing.

As for me, I’ll stay a filer. And when I don’t have time for that, I still have my cardboard box.

Something I’m loving right now…

The post you’ve just read also arrives in inboxes every Tuesday — and subscribers get something extra. Each week, I include a brief, subscriber-only bonus: a short paragraph featuring a practical tip about a tool, book, video, app or resource I’ve tested and loved. This bonus is never published on my website — only in the email. No fluff. No sales pitch. Just one smart recommendation to make your writing life easier. Subscribe to my newsletter to get next Tuesday’s love note.

My video podcast last week addressed where you might be hiding your most important sentence. You can watch the video or read the transcript, and you can also subscribe to my YouTube channel.

*

Do you prefer a messy desk or a tidy one? We can all learn from each other, so please, share your thoughts with my readers and me. To share, please scroll down to the comments, directly underneath the related posts links, below. You don’t have to join Disqus to post! Read my tutorial to learn how to post as a guest. (It’s easy!)

*

Want to share this? You’re welcome to republish any Power Writing issue, in full or in part, on your blog or in your newsletter. Credit me by name and link to www.publicationcoach.com/email-signup/ so your readers can get my free video on how to stop editing while you write. Please wait a week after the issue goes out.

Scroll to Top